New Congress will still be filled with losers
Incoming freshman class includes many who lost previous bids for elected office
OPINION — Once again, the next Congress is going to be filled with losers.
This is not a personal judgment about their character or personality, but a simple recognition that many members have lost races before getting elected. And the incoming class is no different.
I’ve written many versions of this column for more than a decade, and yet the lesson always seems to get lost, no pun intended. Parties routinely attack candidates who enter a race with losses on their record. And, of course, it happened this cycle as well.
“We beat him once. We’ll beat him again,” National Republican Senatorial Committee Chairman Tim Scott declared when Democratic former Sen. Sherrod Brown announced his challenge to appointed GOP Sen. Jon Husted in the summer of 2025.
“Ohioans gladly sent him packing last year, and they’ll not hesitate to toss him aside again,” said a Republican strategist.
Brown lost reelection to Republican Bernie Moreno in 2024 but came back to defeat Husted for the state’s other Senate seat. And Brown is far from the only candidate to avenge a loss with an electoral victory last week.
The fact of the matter is that losing a race doesn’t have to be the end of a political career. Losses can lay the foundation for future success by building name ID or a fundraising network. Or sometimes it takes a change in the political environment or change in circumstances, such as running for an open seat instead of challenging an incumbent.
In addition to Brown, there are more than a dozen losers coming into the next Congress:
- Democratic former Rep. Colin Allred was elected from Texas’ redrawn 33rd District. He lost a 2024 race for Senate to Republican Ted Cruz and even briefly ran for the state’s other Senate seat this cycle, dropping out three months before the primary.
- Democrat Annie Andrews was elected to the Senate from South Carolina. The pediatrician lost to GOP Rep. Nancy Mace in the 1st District in 2022.
- Republican Andy Barr was just elected to the Senate from Kentucky as a sitting member of the House. Barr lost his first race for the 6th District in 2010 before getting elected in 2012.
- Democratic former Rep. Melissa Bean was elected from Illinois’ 8th District. She lost her first run for Congress to GOP Rep. Philip M. Crane in 2002, before defeating him two years later. She lost reelection in the 2010 Republican wave and is now coming back to Capitol Hill in a Democratic wave, although she didn’t need it to win this time. Her suburban Chicago seat is safely Democratic, so the hard work was in the primary.
- Democrat Christina Bohannan was elected from Iowa’s 1st District. The former state legislator lost races in 2022 and 2024 to GOP Rep. Mariannette Miller-Meeks (herself a Hall-of-Fame member of the Losers in Congress list) before defeating the incumbent this year.
- Democrat Victoria Broderick lost to GOP Rep. Scott DesJarlais by 43 points in 2024 but appears on pace to flip Tennessee’s 4th District, though The Associated Press had not called this race as of publication time.
- Republican former Rep. Jerry Carl was elected from Alabama’s 1st District. He lost to fellow Rep. Barry Moore in a 2024 primary after redistricting pitted the two incumbents against each other. But this year Moore ran for Senate, paving the way for Carl to win his former seat.
- Democrat Rebecca Cooke was elected on her third try for Wisconsin’s 3rd District. She lost in the Democratic primary in 2022 and lost the general election to GOP Rep. Derrick Van Orden in 2024, before unseating him this year.
- Republican John Cowan was elected from Georgia’s 11th District. The neurosurgeon lost to Majorie Taylor Greene in a 2020 Republican primary runoff for the 14th District.
- Democrat Abdul El-Sayed was elected to the Senate from Michigan. A 22-point loss to Gretchen Whitmer in the 2018 Democratic primary for governor doesn’t appear to have held him back.
- Democrat Christina Hines was elected from Michigan’s 10th District. She lost a race for Macomb County prosecutor in 2024 before winning the open congressional seat this year.
- Democrat Chuck Hubbard is leading GOP Rep. Virginia Foxx by 99 votes in North Carolina’s 5th District, with the AP yet to call the race. The former journalist lost to Foxx by 19 points two years ago.
- Democrat Troy Jackson was elected to the Senate from Maine after defeating longtime GOP Sen. Susan Collins. In 2014, he lost a bid for the state’s 2nd District, losing in the Democratic primary. This year, he finished third in the Democratic primary for governor before replacing Graham Platner as the Senate nominee.
- Republican Mark Lamb was elected from Arizona’s 5th District. Two years ago, the then-Pinal County sheriff lost the Republican primary for Senate to Kari Lake by 16 points.
- Democratic former Rep. Elaine Luria was elected from Virginia’s 2nd District. She first won the seat in 2018 after unseating GOP Rep. Scott Taylor. Luria won their rematch two years later but lost to Republican Jen Kiggans in 2022. She won her comeback bid against Kiggans last week.
- Democratic former Rep. Ben McAdams was elected from Utah’s newly redrawn 1st District. He was first elected in 2018, defeating GOP Rep. Mia Love in a battleground district but lost reelection two years later. Now he’s back representing a safely blue seat.
- Democrat JoAnna Mendoza was elected from Arizona’s 6th District. The Navy and Marine Corps veteran lost a race for the Arizona Senate in 2020.
- Democrat Richard Ojeda defeated National Republican Congressional Committee Chairman Richard Hudson in North Carolina’s 9th District. The Army veteran ran unsuccessfully for West Virginia’s 3rd District in 2018. During the 2020 cycle, he ran for president (he didn’t win) and lost a Democratic primary for Senate.
- Democrat Richard Pan was elected from California’s redrawn 6th District. The former state senator ran unsuccessfully for Sacramento mayor in 2024.
- Democrat Amish Shah was elected from Arizona’s 1st District. Two years ago, the former state legislator lost the general election to Republican Rep. David Schweikert, who ran for governor this cycle.
- Democrat Janelle Stelson narrowly lost to GOP Rep. Scott Perry in 2024 before winning their rematch this year in Pennsylvania’s 10th District.
- Democrat Shannon Taylor was elected from Virginia’s 1st District. The top prosecutor for Henrico County, she lost a Democratic primary for Virginia attorney general just last year.
- Republican Mark Teixeira was elected from Texas' 21st District. The former MLB first baseman lost playoff series to the Boston Red Sox, Texas Rangers and Detroit Tigers as a member of the Los Angeles Angels and the New York Yankees.
In some instances, though, the losses are piling up.
Republican Rep. John James of Michigan now has three statewide losses on his record. He lost Senate contests in 2018 (taking 46 percent of the vote) and 2020 (48 percent) and came up short in his bid for governor this year (44 percent).
Republican former Sen. John E. Sununu of New Hampshire, who lost reelection in 2008 to Democrat Jeanne Shaheen, fell in his comeback attempt for the open seat last week.
But they could take heart from another repeat loser. Charlie Crist, a former Florida governor and congressman, has had a handful of high-profile losses over the years, including for Senate and two gubernatorial comeback bids. He was just elected mayor of St. Petersburg.
So even though I know it’s a futile request, let’s have a bipartisan agreement not to attack candidates for past losses, because losing doesn’t mean they can’t later pull off a win.